We have all heard the tales, the horror stories if you will; someone has made the effort in attempting an outfit for their persona, only to have it dressed down by an Authenticity Maven, or “Garb Nazi”. The fabric is wrong, the colors are right out of a fantasy novel and should never have been put to fabric, and the embroidery stitches are not period until… ?What??
What do you do? Well for one, I say thank you for your input, write down the information, and get their names Mundane and SCA. Why? So I can thank them later for their help. Yes, their help…Though misguided and opinionated they were only trying to help in their own way. So with their information you can then go and do some research, look for proof and documentation that those colors were period, and so were the embroidery stitches, etc…
Secondly, don’t take it personally, they just cannot seem to help themselves and arguing with them would just make a scene.
If your outfit is as beautiful as you want it to be, WEAR it! With pride! Even if you got that outfit from Gold Key (the SCA clothing rental stall) They should have never cornered you and proselytized their historical garb beliefs. I have a few outfits that sets off the entire Maven’s Guard… and wear them with pride and a huge smile when they start circling, raucous cries of “that’s not period” sounding in the distance like harpies of old.
When did it become the norm to need to document our garb for going to a feast? For myself, I document for myself. But Do we document our garb from the skin out for others in that mystical “just in case” we are brought to the attention to the authenticity mavens? Or just for our own selves and our mental well being that we are indeed making more than the “attempt” and wow doesn’t it feel good?